Federal Appeals Court: San Francisco Limo Driver Had Right to Free Speech in Regards to Officer Battery Charges (CA Penal Code 243(b))

Rabin Nabizadeh
December 2, 2013

In 2008, police officer (name withheld for privacy) gave San Franciscan limo driver (name withheld for privacy) a parking ticket.  However, this was no ordinary exchange.  It seems that both men were driving their respective vehicles when they entered into an argument.  The limo driver pulled over to continue their discussion and, when he did, the officer gave him a ticket for being double-parked.  As you can imagine, the driver wasn’t pleased with this outcome as he was the cause of his having been double-parked in the first place.  He hurled a few insults at the officer, but then the two parted ways.  Just a short while later, the limo driver visited a local fast food restaurant where, by a stroke of fate, the officer was already eating.  The dispute again heated up when the officer followed the driver out of the eatery and sprayed him with pepper spray. The driver responded by spitting at the officer, who then punched the driver in the head.  The driver was originally arrested on battery charges (CA Penal Code 243(b)). Yet, these circumstances have been re-evaluated by the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals pursuant to the driver’s lawsuit against the officer.

The main issue in this case has been the question as to whether or not the driver utterances counted as threatening enough to be considered constitutionally protected or not.  As the federal appeals court has determined, the driver was merely exercising his right to free speech when he disparaged the officer.  U.S. Judge Marilyn Hall Patel stated that law enforcement officials ought to be prepared to put up with a certain amount of “criticism, profane and otherwise.”  It does not, however, mean that an officer of the law can attack a citizen.

 

latest news

January 10, 2023
When You Are Not the Father, But You Are the Suspect

Using genealogical research in solving crimes has become the new go-to for law enforcement agencies worldwide. When a suspect in a decades-old murder case is finally apprehended and brought to trial, the entire community, often the entire world, breathes a sigh of relief. Justice has finally been served. But how just is a criminal prosecution […]

January 10, 2023
Marsy’s Law: Vague Legislation and the Deprivation of Constitutional Rights

As a nation, we tend to react universally to particular catchphrases and soundbites. One term that gets our collective hackles up is the word “victim.” Everyone wants to support and appear sympathetic to the victim; no one wants to seem judgmental of a victim. We have gotten so adept at our collective tiptoeing that we […]

October 5, 2022
9 Steps in a Criminal Defense Case

If you’re in a situation where you are facing criminal charges, the criminal process can be confusing. The justice system has specific steps they follow. Whether federal or state, the prosecuting attorney has the challenge of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. That means obtaining an attorney from a reputable law firm that understands the […]