First District Court of Appeals in Oakland Overturns Murder Conviction

Last Modified: October 15, 2020
August 1, 2013 | Rabin Nabizadeh | Three Strikes, Voluntary Manslaughter

The First District Court of Appeal in Oakland has unanimously determined to reverse the decision of two lower courts to effectively overturn a murder charge against Jamie Thomas in the death of Samuel Navarro.  This higher appeals court decision was made on the basis that jurors in the original trial were not given the option to consider that Thomas had acted in a fit of passion.  Thus, the second-degree-murder charge against him (for which he has already been sentenced 40 years to life) has been overturned.

The original incident happened in 2007 in Oakland, on Pearl Street – a traditionally peaceful neighborhood.  It began with a complaint concerning Thomas’s car blocking the Navarro’s own.  A series of arguments followed, with one ending in several men ganging up on Thomas, beating him.  Testimony revealed that, at that point, Thomas retrieved a rifle from his car – at which point, a threatening Navarro dove for the weapon and Thomas fired.  The original Alameda County jury’s decision was that Thomas had not been acting in self-defense and he was convicted of second-degree murder.  In 2012, an appeals court upheld this decision, including new arguments from the defense that hearing Thomas’s own rap lyrics, which encouraged violent random shootings, had unduly prejudiced the jurors. However, they were not allowed to consider a manslaughter verdict at the time and this is the key sticking point for the First Circuit Court of Appeals.

Importantly, the difference between murder and manslaughter is difficult to decipher in California law.  The main dissimilarity between the two is planning; in order to prove murder, the prosecution must be able to show that there was forethought in the crime.  This, if Thomas indeed acted in the heat of passion, a voluntary manslaughter charge would be more fitting and the penalties lessened to a great degree ( 3, 6, or 11 years in state prison versus the 40 years that Thomas has been sentenced).

latest news

February 27, 2024
What to Do if You’ve Been Arrested for a DUI in San Jose
Being arrested for a DUI in San Jose, CA, can have severe penalties, potentially resulting in jail time, losing your driver's license, and other serious consequences. Here's what to do if facing a DUI conviction after being accused of driving over the legal limit and how a California DUI lawyer can help you resolve your case with [...]
February 25, 2024
What Happens When You Get a DUI?
Getting a DUI (Driving Under the Influence) can be a stressful and life-changing event. It starts the moment a law enforcement officer suspects you've been drinking and driving. This can lead to being pulled over, undergoing a field sobriety test, and possibly being arrested. The consequences of a DUI arrest include legal action, potential jail [...]
February 6, 2024
What Can I Expect After Being Arrested for a DUI in San Jose?

Getting arrested for a DUI in San Jose can be a stressful and confusing experience. You might have many questions about what happens next and what you should do. Knowing the process and what to expect can help you navigate this challenging situation. It’s important to remember that a DUI arrest is severe, and the […]