Study Shows Crime Lab Data To Be Corrupted (CA Penal Code 288)

Rabin Nabizadeh
September 19, 2014

20 years ago, DNA evidence was just becoming mainstream.  Before it became one of the most damning pieces of evidence against accused persons, it had to be vetted, not only by members of the judicial system, but also in the public mind.  In 2014, it seems that no one questions DNA evidence, or the evidence given by crime lab experts when they testify in court.  Their testimony seems to be taken, especially by juries, to be unimpeachable, almost perfect.  However, one study published in Criminal Justice Ethics (by Roger Koppl and Meghan Sacks) reveals that crime labs are regularly given incentives to ‘find’ specific evidence that will falsely lead to convictions.  This kind of evidence, as you can imagine, is of the utmost importance in any trial involving an accusation of sexual assault, child molestation (CA Penal Code 288) or other sex-related crimes.

It seems that crime labs across the country are paid a fee (included in what are often referred to as ‘court costs’) for each guilty verdict that the evidence they provide leads to.  These monies are doled out for DUI convictions, speeding tickets, arson, and any other criminal investigation that you can think of.  For example, the study shows that, in North Carolina, as much as $600 may be awarded by a jury to the crime lab providing evidence, but only after the trial in question has resulted in a conviction.  For instance, CA Penal Code 1404-1405 states that anyone who is convicted of a crime involving DNA evidence must pay for that evidence to have been tested and used against them.   This seems counterintuitive now that there is ample cause to believe that some crime labs must ‘force’ results in order to stay in business.  It seems to be a matter of economics and not simply an interest in carrying out the necessary steps for justice to be served.

 

latest news

February 21, 2023
Different Types of Domestic Violence in California

In California, there are different types of domestic violence. Unfortunately, domestic violence is far more common than many people realize, and it is critical to understand the different categories into which domestic violence might fall. For example, some people might be involved in physical abuse, while others may be in emotional or sexual abuse. Intimate […]

February 21, 2023
California Domestic Violence Classes

You probably realize your life has significantly changed if you have been charged and convicted of domestic violence. You may be facing punishment from the court system, but you might be able to mitigate that punishment if you are willing to take domestic violence classes. The reality is that the justice system focuses just as […]

January 27, 2023
How to Successfully Recant a Domestic Violence Statement

Domestic violence is a problematic situation. Numerous cases of domestic violence take place within a family unit. As a result, the legal process can be messy. In some situations, someone may accuse a family member of domestic violence, only to try to recant their statement later. What does this mean? How is a domestic violence […]