Alameda Market Robbery May Result in Murder Charges for Surviving Accomplice (CA Provocative Act Doctrine)

Alameda Market Robbery May Result in Murder Charges for Surviving Accomplice (CA Provocative Act Doctrine)

Rabin Nabizadeh
August 12, 2013

California’s “Provocative Act doctrine” states that an individual can be held responsible for a murder if they have provoked someone else into killing another person.  Sound complicated?  It is.  Yet, this is only one of several different ways in which one person can be found guilty of a murder that someone else committed (self defense when a victim fears for their life, when an innocent bystander is accidentally killed, or when an accomplice is killed).  However, in 2009, the California Supreme Court added a qualification to that doctrine, that the act of provocation must be premeditated and that every person who participates in the crime must be acting deliberately and willfully.

When 41-year-old Alameda resident and his accomplice of Oakland (names withheld for privacy) walked into the Bonfare Market on High Street in Alameda, there is no question that they intended to rob the store.  What they didn’t know was that an off-duty Sherriff’s deputy (and member of the SWAT team) was sitting in that very market reading the paper.  They also weren’t aware that this officer would decide to take matters into his own hands and shoot both of them with his police weapon, ending in one of their deaths. Now, the survivor faces life in prison at the very least and the death penalty at worst.

Here is the question that should be on everyone’s mind: not how, but why is it that one should be held responsible for the other’s death? What was the off-duty Sheriff’s deputy’s responsibility in all of this? The simple fact is that both entered the Bonfare Market with the intention of committing a robbery, how is one person now more responsible for the other’s death than himself?  Though this particular legal doctrine is, to be sure, meant to deter such crimes, is it really in the best interest of the public or of justice to see the survivor punished for a murder he did not actually commit and to see the deputy go completely free?


latest news

May 18, 2022
Why Term Papers For Sale May Not Be For You

In regards to faculty, many students search for and try out free term papers available on various websites. They are offered free of charge and a number of websites also offer it available with a few terms

April 7, 2022
What Can I Expect After Being Arrested for a DUI in California?
A DUI charge is a severe criminal offense in California. DUI arrests take away a massive part of your driving privilege and could tarnish your reputation. Prior DUI convictions can inflict further damage to your career opportunities, driving rights, and immigration status. This blog will go over what you must expect when facing DUI charges. [...]
April 7, 2022
How Long Does a DUI Stay on Your Record in California?
DUI cases may stay on your criminal record forever. The United States sees DUI as a serious traffic crime punishable with grave penalties. Fighting your way through a DUI case is a challenging task. But, it doesn't mean you can't do anything about it. There are legal options available for you, depending on the nature [...]