Valley Springs: 12-year-old Arrest in Leila Fowler Murder (CA Penal Code §187(a))

Rabin Nabizadeh
May 14, 2013

When Leila Fowler (8) was found stabbed to death in the kitchen of her family’s ranch style home, it was her brother (12) who seemed most upset.  Now, the young boy has been arrested in connection with the case pursuant to CA Penal Code §187(a), even though there seems to be little evidence to support this.  By all accounts, including the testimony of the children’s mother, the Calaveras County Sherriff’s Department is grasping at straws.  The boy’s original testimony was that a strange man with silver hair had broken into the home, killed Fowler, and run – that his sister was the victim of an attempted burglary turned home invasion.

Because of the violent and intimate nature of the crime, this 12-year-old will soon find his fate in the hands of a juvenile court judge – and perhaps in the hands of psychiatrists and psychologists assigned to the task of determining his mental health. In the state of California, a juvenile can be charged as an adult when it is deemed appropriate, but the offender has to be aged 14 years or older.  This is because the goal of the California juvenile justice system is not punishment; it’s rehabilitation. Yet, there are some cases in which much younger children, like this boy, may be deemed “too bad” to be considered redeemable – and the decision as to whether this boy will face life in prison or 25 years in jail will be up to the judge in the case.

A crime like this is heartbreaking; it’s as simple as that.  However, when we turn the harsh and unyielding eye of justice on to a young child, the situation becomes even less palatable.  The question on everyone’s mind is whether or not this boy was capable of changing so swiftly from a loving brother who never fought with his sister to a cold-blooded murderer.  The odds are that this is an unlikely scenario and that the Calaveras County Sherriff’s Department will end up with egg on their faces soon enough.

latest news

January 10, 2023
When You Are Not the Father, But You Are the Suspect

Using genealogical research in solving crimes has become the new go-to for law enforcement agencies worldwide. When a suspect in a decades-old murder case is finally apprehended and brought to trial, the entire community, often the entire world, breathes a sigh of relief. Justice has finally been served. But how just is a criminal prosecution […]

January 10, 2023
Marsy’s Law: Vague Legislation and the Deprivation of Constitutional Rights

As a nation, we tend to react universally to particular catchphrases and soundbites. One term that gets our collective hackles up is the word “victim.” Everyone wants to support and appear sympathetic to the victim; no one wants to seem judgmental of a victim. We have gotten so adept at our collective tiptoeing that we […]

October 5, 2022
9 Steps in a Criminal Defense Case

If you’re in a situation where you are facing criminal charges, the criminal process can be confusing. The justice system has specific steps they follow. Whether federal or state, the prosecuting attorney has the challenge of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. That means obtaining an attorney from a reputable law firm that understands the […]